Skip navigation
Have a gift or promo code? Get started
Skip content
Shop small. Gift big. Support Love's Sweet Arrow by giving audiobook gifts. Start shopping

Same audiobooks.
Different story.

Fresh Fiction thinks that you’ll love listening to Botched Butterscotch through makes it possible for you to buy audiobooks through Love's Sweet Arrow. Get your first month of membership for free and choose from 150,000+ audiobooks, including New York Times bestsellers and hand-curated selections from expert booksellers across our partner stores.

You’ll enjoy great audiobooks every month, and Fresh Fiction will earn a free audiobook with your first full-price monthly payment.

Get your first month for free

Gift audiobook memberships

Shop Love's Sweet Arrow and gift audiobook memberships! You pick the membership (1, 3, 6, or 12 months/credits), your gift recipient picks their own audiobooks, and Love's Sweet Arrow is supported by your purchase.

Start shopping App

Botched Butterscotch

Amish Candy Shop Mystery: Book #2
By Amanda Flower
Narrated by Rebecca Mitchell /  2 hours 30 minutes

Amanda Flower presents Book 2.5 in the Amish Candy Shop Mystery series. Read more »


$22.99 USD

Get for free with membership
  Add to Wish List

Almost ready!

In order to save audiobooks to your Wish List you must be signed in to your account.

      Log in       Create account
Featured bookseller pick

A Good Neighborhood

“Actions have consequences and we don’t always like the result but getting there is quite the trip. Powerfully moving story that is well told by a great narrator.”

HearthFire Books and Treats image Mollie, HearthFire Books and Treats

This holiday season is crucial for bookstores weathering the financial challenges of 2020—it could determine whether they remain open or are forced to close their doors.

Join the movement and #ShopLocalBookstores.

Learn more

As featured in
Fast Company
USA Today
New York Times
The Washington Post
Oprah Magazine
Globe & Mail
Boing Boing
Book Riot
Shop small. Gift big. Support Love's Sweet Arrow by giving audiobook gifts. Start shopping
Love's Sweet Arrow

Love's Sweet Arrow is proud to partner with to give you a great audiobook experience.