The Method

Reviews

[An] engaging and meticulously researched history … Like a good 19 century omniscient novelist, Butler hops seamlessly among his characters’ points of view while recounting their lives and times … Butler’s history is an indispensable account of a revolution in acting that ramified beyond the theater. It’s hard to believe that a style of performance developed amid the turbulence of revolutionary Russia would change Hollywood forever, but the author Isaac Butler makes a compulsively readable case for just that in this ‘biography’ of Method acting. Thoroughly engrossing … Butler makes an airtight case for the Method as an artistic revolution on par with other mid-century advances. Delicious, humane, probing, and beautifully researched, [The Method is] a cultural history that reaches beyond its immediate subject to point at the currents moving under America herself. Butler’s lively, well-researched and marvelously readable book isn’t just for actors, but also for anyone who loves watching them … The Method is a rich book, highly entertaining but also gratifyingly specific, about the point of connection between actor and observer, the lightning flash between us and them that, when it happens, is impossible to adequately describe or explain. If it’s grand, it’s also granular, a gift of humility drawn from an actor’s ego. Intense, deeply researched, historically alert, well-written, eminently readable (and gossipy). Meticulous, immersive As Isaac Butler shows in his pitch-perfect ‘biography’ of the acting method that has consumed generations of actors, the main thing to know about the Method is that it means different things to different people. Just like real people do. Richly researched and rigorously argued, The Method is a guide to an American school of acting we understand very little for how much we talk about it. Butler knows how to liven up history by focusing on human personalities and foibles. Even as he writes about the various legends who sculpted modern acting, he never fails to find the humor and humanity in his subjects. Seminal acting gurus like Konstantin Stanislavski and Stella Adler are giants, but Butler never loses sight of the fact that they were also goofy theater kids. Fascinating … an exhaustive yet never exhausting account of the system that would define the American stage and screen, all the while showing how the craft of acting—and our perception of that craft—has evolved over time. Expertly and exactingly told … Butler clearly parses the murky divisions that continue to define the Method, then and today. Intelligent and entertaining … Butler’s appreciation of acting—and art in general—as an expression of the temper of its times brings welcome insights throughout the book. Like The World Only Spins Forward, the excellent oral history of Angels in America he coauthored, The Method gives us cultural history that’s both smart and wonderful fun to read. Butler accomplishes what the Method’s devotees sought to do in their performances, bringing color and dimension to figures who might have been boxed into archetypal roles (omniscient godhead or exploitative charlatan) and presenting them to us in all their brilliant, infuriating complexity. The scope of the book is sweeping, the figures entering and exiting the narrative often larger-than-life, but each quote and anecdote Butler chooses to include draws them close enough to touch. An engaging and accessible account of a niche, complicated subject … [Butler] dispels common misconceptions about the Method and shows just how much 21st century actors owe to a handful of acting teachers and their esoteric ideas … a fascinating study in how intellectual movements splinter. What a production! … A print-form master class in The Method. This comprehensive history of the great American acting style is the present and likely future standard-bearer for books on the subject. Elegantly written, filled with remarkable detail and incisive commentary, Isaac Butler’s sweeping historical epic is the literary equivalent of an irresistible binge-watch, propelled by emotional twists and turns, surprising cliffhangers, and a cast of the greatest actors, directors, writers, and teachers of the last two centuries. The fact that he has done all that while also writing what I think is the best and most important book about acting I’ve ever read is a major achievement. This is an essential book for anyone in the acting profession as well as for anyone who’s ever wondered ‘How did they learn all those lines?’ Butler is the perfect guide—brilliant, insightful, and slyly funny—through the long life of contemporary performance. The Method, like its subject, is forceful, restless, and, above all, real. Riveting and comprehensive. A narrative one doesn't simply read, but experiences. An intoxicating mix of history, illuminating character studies, delicious gossip, and a persuasive and revelatory argument about how the Method has been used, abused, and misunderstood. Essential reading, glorious reading. A brilliant book that brims with exuberance, compassion and—of course—a keen eye for the dramatic. The Method is erudite and deeply researched, but it’s also vibrant, energetic, accessible, and often very funny—rich with personalities and packed with insight. Vividly recreates a fascinating moment of time, filled with creativity, rivalry, artistry, and absurdity, that profoundly transformed American film and theater, with reverberations still being felt today. A rich, rollicking dive into one of the most influential philosophies of the century, The Method. Tracing a century of schisms, experiments, breakthroughs, and breakdowns, Butler brings to life the desperate, sometimes dark struggle to turn acting into a science and a faith. Isaac Butler has turned a brilliant concept into a compulsively readable cultural history that’s truly unique. I was entertained and enlightened! Expand reviews