Bad Naturalist

Reviews

“With dry humor and an always engaging voice, Paula Whyman takes us on an entertaining and unexpected journey restoring a wild Virginia mountaintop. Bad Naturalist is a master class in ecology, humility, and perseverance, that will have you thinking about mid-life larks, plants, and gardens, in a whole new light.”
 —Susan Coll, former president of the PEN/Faulkner Foundation and author of Real Life and Other Fictions "How can someone who knows nothing about ecological restoration successfully rehab 200 acres of retired farmland? In Bad Naturalist, her self-deprecating, humorous, and thoroughly engaging book, Paula Whyman tells us exactly how. She describes the many pitfalls, explains how she triumphed over them, and details the many benefits of persevering, both for herself and for her mountaintop ecosystem. Why should landowners read this book? Because they own—and need to restore—most of the landscape, an awesome responsibility whose meaning Whyman has distilled for us.”—Douglas W. Tallamy, New York Times bestselling author of Nature’s Best Hope "In Bad Naturalist, Whyman writes with grace and good humor about the wonderful stubbornness of the natural world--and of her attempts to restore it. Down-to-earth yet poetic, impeccably researched and intensely personal, Whyman's charming, good-natured prose is a joy to read. Bad Naturalist feels like a conversation with your best friend, your quirky neighbor, and the most remarkable adventurer you've ever met. At once the story of an amateur naturalist and a moving family history, Whyman chronicles her all-too-human foibles and her even more human determination in this thoughtful, wry nonfiction debut.”—Courtney Sender, author of In Other Lifetimes All I’ve Lost Comes Back to Me “Whyman's writing comes alive when exploring the history of people and place among the Piedmont and Blue Ridge, and then in the weaving of living with and reviving nature in all of the inevitable tribulations that feed a soul and liberate life. No garden, even a meadow, is perfect: perfection rests in the struggle to do better and be better, to leave the land healthier, and to create stories tied to place that help us remember we are nature figuring itself out, too. Bad Naturalist is one such story.”—Benjamin Vogt, author of A New Garden Ethic and Prairie Up "Bad Naturalist is a thoughtful, engaging, and fascinating exploration of the riddle of land stewardship. What is a weed? What should you eliminate, and what can you protect? And what does it mean to own property? Whyman is eager, curious, and humble in the description of her journey as the owner of a 200-acre mountaintop in Virginia. She draws on all sorts of sources in her narrative —philosophical, poetic, literary and ecological. As a gardener and modest landowner, myself, I found it instructive and deeply absorbing. Brava!"—Roxana Robinson, author of Leaving "A brilliant, richly layered exploration of the natural world, Paula Whyman’s gripping tale embeds the reader on a mountaintop, sweeping us through the landscape and her life while braiding memoir, biodiversity, expertise, and doubt, along with inevitable setbacks that she counters with sheer determination. Whyman, a ‘pretty good’ naturalist, is the perfect guide to today’s urgent questions, proposing some unexpected answers and delivering it all in unputdownable prose, with a sense of humor and a joyful spirit."
 —Jordan Goodman, author of Planting the World: Joseph Banks and His Collectors, an Adventurous History of Botany Expand reviews