Butcher

Reviews

“Butcher, by Joyce Carol Oates: A ghastly and harrowing page-turner based on facts. That a large part is set in the New Jersey Asylum for Female Lunatics should tell you all you need to know. Faint of heart? Stay away.”
—Stephen King via Twitter

“[Butcher] has the feverish energy, narrative propulsion and descriptive amplitude of much of [Oates’s] earlier work. . . . Oates, as is her wont, succeeds in creating a world that is apart from our own yet familiar, making it impossible to dismiss her observations about twisted natures and random acts of violence. . . . We have become so used to the notion of the recognizable auteur blazing through the artifice of fiction and calling attention to his or her self that Oates’s approach feels like a singularly uncommon one. Long may she run.”
—Daphne Merkin, The New York Times Book Review

“Gripping. . . . Oates empathetically ranges among her characters and doesn’t veil any of the gruesomeness of her story, but rather describes [the surgical] experiments with matter of fact evenness, heightening the horror. Bravura storytelling.”
—Vogue, “The Best Books of 2024”

“This well-researched historical tale of medical experiments gone haywire looks to be a perfect match with Joyce Carol Oates’ visceral style and violent explorations of American sins. . . . Butcher is JCO at her best, and an essential text for understanding America’s long war on women.”
—CrimeReads, “The Best Historical Fiction of 2024”

“Oates’ daring tale of grotesque medical experiments and other injustices is unnerving, illuminating, suspenseful, mythic, and, thankfully, tempered by transcendence and love.”
—Booklist, starred

“A creepy, circuitous tale—one based on actual history . . . Vintage Oates: splendidly written, and a useful warning to choose your doctors wisely.”
—Kirkus

“Deliciously arch . . . Oates’s scathing indictment of the physical and psychological treatment of women by the medical establishment makes for compulsive but challenging reading. Unlike the ghastly procedures depicted, Oates’s inventive gothic novel pays off.”
—Publishers Weekly

“[Oates] takes this very real nightmare of [the ‘father of gyno-psychiatry’] and knits together a story about a young Irish servant who becomes Weir’s ‘subject,’ but also the object of his downfall. Sounds like the perfect American novel, delving deep into the horrors of invention.”
—Lit Hub, “Most Anticipated Books of 2024” Expand reviews