Dark Shadows - The Last Stop
Dark Shadows
- By: David Llewellyn
- Narrated by: Jerry Lacy, Lara Parker & W Morgan Sheppard
- Length: 1 hour 8 minutes
Description
Tony Peterson is a lucky man. He's just caught the last train back to Collinsport. It's been a good day – he's renewed an old friendship and been offered a job he cannot refuse. His life is about to change.
But Tony Peterson's luck has just run out. The last train home will turn out to be a very long journey. Will Tony be able to trust the only other survivor? And what decision will Tony make when he's presented with another offer he cannot refuse?
Gift audiobook memberships
You pick the membership (1, 3, 6, or 12 months/credits), your gift recipient picks their own audiobooks, and your local bookstore is supported by your purchase.
Start shopping
Dark Shadows Series
The Curse of Collinwood
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 7 minutes
Abridged: No
The Curse of Collinwood (May 1968)
Upset over the death of Ernest Collins, Victoria begins to believe that phantoms are haunting her. Are they figments of her imagination? As the threats to her life become very real, she is forced to accept the horrifying truth.
The strange figures are not phantoms but the bodies of Derek and Esther Collins,... Read more »
Dark Shadows
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 15 minutes
Abridged: No
Dark Shadows (December 1966)
Despite warnings from the townspeople, Victoria Winters accepts the offer to come to the strange Collinwood as Governess. For some curious reason she feels the secret of her past may be uncovered in the bleak manor high on Widow’s Hill.
From the Moment she arrives, Victoria becomes the target of someone in the house... Read more »
Barnabas Collins Versus the Warlock
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 10 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas Collins Vs. the Warlock (October 1969)
David Collins and Amy Jennings, two charming, innocent children are suddenly turned into demons. At first their pranks only annoy Maggie Evans, their governess. But soon she realizes they have become malicious, bent on destroying all of Collinwood.
Convinced the children are possessed by a... Read more »
Barnabas Collins and the Gypsy Witch
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 56 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas Collins and the Gypsy Witch (March 1970)
Warned by a gypsy witch that violent death will surround her, Roxanna Collins turns to her distant cousin, Barnabas, for help.
But Barnabas is also in trouble. For when Roxanna’s father and brother are murdered, suspicion centers on Barnabas. Even Roxanna, who feels she is under some strange... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Mummy's Curse
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 50 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Mummy's Curse (April 1970)
When Professor Anthony Collins decides to catalog his Egyptian relics at Collinwood, he brings with him the mummy of King Rehotip, who “died” over two thousand years ago. Only the professor knows that Rehotip is really in a state of suspended animation.
One night, the professor brings the... Read more »
The Foe of Barnabas Collins
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 20 minutes
Abridged: No
The Foe of Barnabas Collins (July 1969)
Barnabas befriends lovely Paula Jennings right after her marriage to strange, mysterious Christopher Jennings. He feels protective towards the lovely heiress because he suspects Christopher is the werewolf who has been ravaging the countryside. When Christopher is joined by Melissa Henry (the reincarnation... Read more »
The Peril of Barnabas Collins
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 1 minute
Abridged: No
The Peril of Barnabas Collins (November 1969)
After falling in love with beautiful heiress Diana Hastings, Barnabas Collins makes a desperate attempt to find a cure for his vampire curse. He summons to Collinwood Dr. Rudolf Padrel, a strange scientist who claims he can develop a serum that will make Barnabas a normal man again.
But as time... Read more »
Barnabas Collins and Quentin's Demon
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 47 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas Collins and Quentin's Demon (February 1970)
When Quentin Collins invited Lara Balfour to Collinwood, they knew each other only from the correspondence that had grown out of Quentin’s admiration for the haunting waltz her father had composed.
Soon Quentin professes to love Lara—but is his love really a threat? His first wife’s throat was... Read more »
The Secret of Barnabas Collins
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 18 minutes
Abridged: No
Secret of Barnabas Collins (January 1969)
Here is another never-before-told story of the handsome, mysterious 175-year-old vampire.
While searching for the woman who will replace his long-lost Josette, and thus end the terrible curse upon him, Barnabas meets lovely Clare Duncan. The story, set in 1870, of their romance—and of the terror it... Read more »
Victoria Winters
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 55 minutes
Abridged: No
Victoria Winters (March 1967)
Still trying to uncover the secret of her own identity, Victoria Winters continues her life at Collinwood. The unexpected arrival of mysterious strangers at the brooding manor instills terrible fears in her.
Horrified at their lies and their evil, menacing gestures, Victoria wonders if these guest have come to kill... Read more »
Strangers at Collins House
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 26 minutes
Abridged: No
Strangers at Collins House (September 1967)
Victoria Winters at last feels she has a clue to her own identity when she meets elderly Henry Collins. He secretly gives her the jewels which once belonged to his lost love — a woman Victoria strangely resembles.
After receiving the gift, Victoria is suddenly terrified by attacks on her life which are... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Avenging Ghost
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 30 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Avenging Ghost (May 1970)
When the jury of which Roger Collins is chairman finds Harriet Barnes guilty of murder, she swears vengeance on the entire Collins family, then kills herself.
Soon, Celia Dalton, a guest at Collinwood, starts suffering strange spells. Each time she does, someone at Collinwood is violently... Read more »
Barnabas Collins and the Mysterious Ghost
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 53 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas Collins and the Mysterious Ghost (January 1970)
Collinwood is plagued with a series of menacing events when a ballet troupe arrives there to perform for the summer tourists. One girl in particular, the beautiful Diana Samson, whom Barnabas has come to love, is repeatedly attacked by a mysterious, invisible presence.
When the star of... Read more »
The Demon of Barnabas Collins
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 6 minutes
Abridged: No
The Demon of Barnabas Collins (April 1969)
The arrival of a movie company at Collinwood gives Barnabas a chance to escape Angelique’s awful curse—the curse which has made him one of the living dead.
Barnabas meets and falls in love with beautiful film star, Rita Glenn. In order to save him, she introduces him to the mysterious Dr. Moreno who has... Read more »
The Phantom and Barnabas Collins
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 30 minutes
Abridged: No
The Phantom and Barnabas Collins (September 1969)
Maggie Evans visits the Collins family graveyard and is transported back in time to the year 1880. There she awakes, an amnesia victim, at a Collinwood she barely recognizes. All that seems familiar are the house itself and the family’s guest, Barnabas Collins.
Slowly, Maggie learns she is... Read more »
The Mystery of Collinwood
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 9 minutes
Abridged: No
The Mystery of Collinwood (January 1968)
Victoria stood on the ledge known as Suicide Cliffs and stared down at the raging surf and jagged rocks below. Next to her stood Professor Mark Veno, a mysterious visitor to Collinwood. He spoke to her in a low, sinister voice. “Think of all those who threw themselves from these very rocks.”His eyes... Read more »
Dark Shadows 1.4 The Rage Beneath
By: Scott Alan Woodward
Narrated by: David Selby, Kathryn Leigh Scott, Lara Parker, John Karlen & Robert Rodan
Length: 1 hour 13 minutes
Abridged: No
As a storm rages across Collinsport, ancient forces are stirring in the town. The ocean holds dark secrets for the Collins family - secrets that must be revealed once and for all. As a malevolent power takes hold, Quentin faces a final confrontation... Read more »
Learn more
Barnabas Collins
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours 13 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas Collins (November 1968)
Barnabas Collins, the 175 year-old vampire, is introduced in this story of gothic suspense.
Your blood will grow cold as you read the never-before-told story of the foggy night in 1899 when Barnabas Collins first arrived in Collinwood. You’ll chill to the full horror of the real truth about Barnabas—a secret so... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Serpent
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 38 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Serpent (December 1970)
Professor Gerald Collins returns to Collinwood from an archaeological expedition to Mexico with several crates of animals—giant rats poisonous snakes and rare lizards. His daughter, Irma, turns to Barnabas for help. She fears her father also brought back a Quetzalcoatl, the terrible, cursed... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Frightened Bride
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 26 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Frightened Bride (October 1970)
Ann and John Hayward’s honeymoon at Collinwood slowly turns into a series of nightmares.
Soon after their arrival, John, who is recovering from a war injury, falls victim to strange, violent spells. In a fit of irrational jealousy, he accuses his wife of falling in love with Barnabas... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Crystal Coffin
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 6 hours
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Crystal Coffin (July 1970)
Heiress Betty Ward is worried about her twin sister, who has eloped with Jeremy Frene. She follows them from Paris to Frene estate at Collinwood—but arrives too late!
Her twin is dead, victim of a mysterious illness. Her body has been sealed in a crystal coffin and kept in a... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Sea Ghost
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 19 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Sea Ghost (August 1971)
Centuries ago, Jenny Swift ruled her cutthroat crew of pirates with a blacksnake whip. Now, legend says, her ghost still guards the treasure ship where it sank in Collinsport Cove, meting out death to those rash enough to seek her gold. But Norah Bliss and her father, both salvage experts, are... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Scorpio Curse
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 36 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Scorpio Curse (November 1970)
Is the sign of Scorpio the mark of death?
Terror reigns at Collinwood when several patients at a nearby... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Haunted Refrain
By: Aaron Lamont
Narrated by: David Selby & Karen Jean Olds
Length: 1 hour 7 minutes
Abridged: No
Barbara loves her husband and their new home. But something is missing from her life. Something she can't explain... Until, one day, she finds it.
An old gramophone sits in the attic. And, on it, she hears the voice of man called Quentin Collins. A voice that talks back to her, begging her for help.
Something has trapped the soul of Quentin... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Poisoned Soul
By: James Goss
Narrated by: Nancy Barrett & Roy Thinnes
Length: 1 hour 11 minutes
Abridged: No
Evil haunts a school near Collinwood. A strange creature is attacking young girls, and the headmistress of Worthington Hall is forced to barricade her school against it.
But Miss Charity Trask has problems of her own. She fears she's not in her right mind. She's seeing ghostly visions, and soon a strange spirit possesses her. Should she go... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Magic Potion
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 37 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Magic Potion (January 1971)
This story marks a sudden shift in the characterization of Quentin Collins, who up to this point in the range had been portrayed as an enemy of Barnabas. Barnabas predicts trouble for Collinwood when Nicholas Freeze, in whose antique shop Carolyn Stoddard works, discovers a centuries-old... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Haunted Cave
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 42 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and The Haunted Cave (September 1970)
Harriet Turnbridge asks Barnabas Collins for help after her husband, her brother-in-law, and father-in-law are found dead, their throats savagely ripped open.
The police insist the killer is a mad beast. Harriet thinks that the phantom recently seen at Collinwood is responsible. Barnabas... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Nightmare Assassin
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 20 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Nightmare Assassin (June 1970)
Carolyn Stoddard is knocked unconscious when the sports car she and Barnabas are riding in skids on a patch of ice. She regains consciousness in Collinwood with Barnabas and Quentin Collins at her side—but the year is 1870! And Collinwood is being terrorized by a savage killer. Carolyn... Read more »
Barnabas, Quentin and the Body Snatchers
By: Marilyn Ross
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 5 hours 23 minutes
Abridged: No
Barnabas, Quentin and the Body Snatchers (February 1971)
In an alien spaceship hidden in a swamp near Collinwood, Roger Collins and his friend, space scientist Murdock Gray, lie bound and gagged—yet no one even knows they are missing! For their captors are able to change shapes at will, and two of them have “become” Roger and Murdock. Although... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Creeping Fog
By: Simon Guerrier
Narrated by: David Selby & Matthew Waterhouse
Length: 1 hour 13 minutes
Abridged: No
London, 1941. Quentin Collins need not fear the bombing because he is immortal, but there's much else to be scared of. The voices of his past will not rest. They are the ghosts of those he's lost. And there are other voices… A creeping fog reaching out to him...
Taking refuge in an old museum will not help Quentin either, for the museum has... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Harvest of Souls
By: James Goss
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott, Jonathon Marx & Colin Baker
Length: 1 hour 17 minutes
Abridged: No
Collinsport is over. And, after recent events, Maggie Evans just doesn't care any more. She grew up here, she fell in love here, she grieved here. But no more. Maggie wants out.
But there's a problem as this town won't let her go. Collinsport has unfinished business with Maggie.
Maggie finds herself trapped in the empty streets, pursued by an old... Read more »
Dark Shadows - Bloodlust Volume 02
By: Alan Flanagan, Will Howells & Joseph Lidster
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott, David Selby & Lara Parker
Length: 5 hours 2 minutes
Abridged: No
Some describe it as the town at the edge of the world.
When Melody and Michael Devereux come to Collinsport on their honeymoon, they don't know the secrets that are hidden behind closed doors. But those secrets will be unearthed when an innocent is viciously murdered.
Collinsport will be a town divided. One woman's rise to power will lead to... Read more »
Dark Shadows - Dress Me in Dark Dreams
By: Marty Ross
Narrated by: Terry Crawford & Amber Benson
Length: 1 hour 5 minutes
Abridged: No
Collinwood in the 19th century is a lonely place. While her brothers experience the world, the young Judith Collins must stay and tend to her grandmother, Edith.
Judith, though, has secret dreams of romance. She sees herself dancing in a beautiful dress with a dashing stranger. But the man of her dreams is becoming increasingly real.
Soon Judith... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Night Whispers
By: Stuart Manning
Narrated by: Jonathan Frid, John Karlen & Barbara Steele
Length: 49 minutes
Abridged: No
Long since released from his vampire curse, Barnabas Collins has settled into a new life away from the supernatural. But when a powerful storm sweeps through Collinsport, the elements bring back memories of past sins. Who is the mysterious spirit whispering in the darkness, and what is its connection with Barnabas?
Jonathan Frid returns as... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Ghost Watcher
By: Stuart Manning
Narrated by: Kathryn Leigh Scott & Alec Newman
Length: 1 hour 7 minutes
Abridged: No
As Maggie Evans leaves the Windcliff Institute, she begins to build a new life for herself away from the Collins family. But when an enigmatic stranger arrives in town, Maggie finds herself plunged into a world of intrigue and danger... Read more »
Learn more
Dark Shadows 1.1 The House of Despair
By: Stuart Manning
Narrated by: David Selby, Lara Parker, John Karlen & Kathryn Leigh Scott
Length: 1 hour 12 minutes
Abridged: No
After years of wandering the world, Quentin Collins is coming home. But the Collinwood that awaits him is not the sanctuary he remembers. As Collinsport hides in fear from otherworldly powers, Quentin vows to unite old friends and reclaim his birthright.. Read more »
Learn more
Dark Shadows - The Eternal Actress
By: Nev Fountain
Narrated by: Donna McKechnie & Andrew Collins
Length: 1 hour 9 minutes
Abridged: No
Helvetica Stanhope is a famous actress with a dark secret. She's afraid to sleep – for in her dreams, she sees the terrible deaths of her friends. Dreams which come horribly true. But that is not her dark secret.
Gideon Wilder is a Hollywood reporter with a dark secret. He knows the truth about Helvetica Stanhope and he's going to tell all. But... Read more »
Dark Shadows 2.2 Kingdom of the Dead Part 2
By: Stuart Manning & Eric Wallace
Narrated by: David Selby, Lara Parker, Kathryn Leigh Scott, John Karlen & Jerry Lacy
Length: 56 minutes
Abridged: No
The Lorelei has gone and Barnabas and Quentin are missing, presumed dead. As Willie attempts to protect Maggie, Angelique begins to uncover the truth about Barnabas and Quentin’s fate. But a powerful force is waiting in the wings... Read more »
Learn more
Dark Shadows - The Blind Painter
By: Jonathan Morris
Narrated by: Roger Davis, Nicola Bryant & Lizzie Hopley
Length: 1 hour 5 minutes
Abridged: No
The year is 1893, and struggling artist Charles Delaware Tate works alone in a garret in New York City. Frustrated by his lack of artistic genius, he seems doomed to a life of misery and failure. And then he meets Eloise Verinder... and his whole world changes.
The year is 1920. Charles Delaware Tate now lives alone in a sanatorium. But he’s... Read more »
Dark Shadows - Curse of the Pharoah
By: Stephen Mark Rainey
Narrated by: Nancy Barrett & Marie Wallace
Length: 1 hour 15 minutes
Abridged: No
Egyptologist Dr Gretchen Warwick has come to Collinwood looking for the answers to life in the hereafter. At first, Carolyn cannot understand why Warwick needs her help, but she soon discovers she is the key to the dark world on the other side of death... Read more »
Learn more
Dark Shadows - The Darkest Shadow
By: Nev Fountain
Narrated by: David Selby & Donna McKechnie
Length: 2 hours 26 minutes
Abridged: No
Olivia Corey has been offered the role of her life. They’re making a movie called The Curse of Collinwood by Mr D Curtis. Apparently it’s based on a true story about an old house in Maine where all manner of terrible things happen.
Olivia is offered the role of ‘Amanda Harris’, a woman created from a painting, destined to fall in love with a... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Phantom Bride
By: Mark Thomas Passmore
Narrated by: Jerry Lacy & Lara Parker
Length: 1 hour 2 minutes
Abridged: No
A liner sailing across the ocean to London. Happy couples enjoying a relaxing few days of fine food, fine wine and the fresh sea air. Until they start dying. Because also on board is a ghost seeking vengeance. A ghost of a woman who died in 1929.
Private detective Tony Peterson and the witch Cassandra find themselves embroiled in yet another... Read more »
Dark Shadows 2.1 Kingdom of the Dead Part 1
By: Stuart Manning & Eric Wallace
Narrated by: David Selby, Lara Parker, Kathryn Leigh Scott, John Karlen & Jerry Lacy
Length: 59 minutes
Abridged: No
The Lorelei has gone and Barnabas and Quentin are missing, presumed dead. As Willie attempts to protect Maggie, Angelique begins to uncover the truth about Barnabas and Quentin’s fate. But a powerful force is waiting in the wings... Read more »
Learn more
Dark Shadows 2.4 Kingdom of the Dead Part 4
By: Stuart Manning & Eric Wallace
Narrated by: David Selby, Lara Parker, Kathryn Leigh Scott, John Karlen & Jerry Lacy
Length: 1 hour 3 minutes
Abridged: No
The Lorelei has gone and Barnabas and Quentin are missing, presumed dead. As Willie attempts to protect Maggie, Angelique begins to uncover the truth about Barnabas and Quentin’s fate. But a powerful force is waiting in the wings... Read more »
Learn more
Dark Shadows - The Enemy Within
By: Will Howells
Narrated by: Christopher Pennock, Lisa Richards & Nancy Barrett
Length: 1 hour 9 minutes
Abridged: No
Cyrus Longworth has a secret. On the outside, he's the quiet handyman helping out with odd jobs. But his neighbours don't know about the voice inside his head.
Sabrina Jennings has a secret. She's just moved in across the street, here to teach at the local school. But her new husband is nowhere to be seen.
They could live happily ever after. But... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Last Stop
By: David Llewellyn
Narrated by: Jerry Lacy, Lara Parker & W Morgan Sheppard
Length: 1 hour 8 minutes
Abridged: No
Tony Peterson is a lucky man. He's just caught the last train back to Collinsport. It's been a good day – he's renewed an old friendship and been offered a job he cannot refuse. His life is about to change.
But Tony Peterson's luck has just run out. The last train home will turn out to be a very long journey. Will Tony be able to trust the only... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Voodoo Amulet
By: Mark Thomas Passmore
Narrated by: Jerry Lacy & Lara Parker
Length: 1 hour 6 minutes
Abridged: No
Supernatural investigator Tony Peterson is summoned by the devious witch Cassandra Collins to the bustling city of New Orleans. On the trail of the mysterious Voodoo Amulet, they're hunted through bars, hotels, train stations and graveyards by the police, criminals, black magicians and zombies.
Can Tony and Cassandra escape with their lives...... Read more »
Dark Shadows 2.3 Kingdom of the Dead Part 3
By: Stuart Manning & Eric Wallace
Narrated by: David Selby, Lara Parker, Kathryn Leigh Scott, John Karlen & Jerry Lacy
Length: 1 hour 1 minute
Abridged: No
The Lorelei has gone and Barnabas and Quentin are missing, presumed dead. As Willie attempts to protect Maggie, Angelique begins to uncover the truth about Barnabas and Quentin’s fate. But a powerful force is waiting in the wings... Read more »
Learn more
Dark Shadows - The Happier Dead
By: Adam Usden
Narrated by: Stephanie Ellyne, John Chancer & Murray Melvin
Length: 1 hour 17 minutes
Abridged: No
No one is dying at Collinsport Hospital, even those who wish to.
When student parapsychologist Amy Jennings is rushed into intensive care, she reluctantly begins to investigate, and soon finds the hospital morgue is anything but empty. But who is behind it? And what could they possibly want?
Amy might be guaranteed to make it out alive, but she is... Read more »
Dark Shadows - The Fall of the House of Trask
By: Joseph Lidster
Narrated by: Nancy Barrett, Jerry Lacy & Marie Wallace
Length: 1 hour 17 minutes
Abridged: No
1941: The Reverend Gregory Trask has come back from Hell to be reunited with his daughter, Charity.
But why has he returned? Is he really free of the influence of The Dark Lord? The ghost of Pansy Faye doesn’t think so and is keeping a close eye on him. Torn between the spirit who haunts her and a father returned from beyond the grave, whose side... Read more »