Skip content
Celebrate indie bookstores with our limited-time sale! Shop the sale
The One We Fell in Love With by Paige Toon
  Send as gift   Add to Wish List

Almost ready!

In order to save audiobooks to your Wish List you must be signed in to your account.

      Log in       Create account
IBD balloon logo

Shop the sale

In celebration of Independent Bookstore Day, shop our limited-time sale on bestselling audiobooks from April 22nd-28th. Don’t miss out—purchases support your local bookstore!

Shop now

The One We Fell in Love With

$22.50

Get for $14.99 with membership
Length 11 hours 37 minutes
Language English
Narrators Andrew Wincott & Juliette Burton

This audiobook uses AI narration.

We’re taking steps to make sure AI narration is transparent.

Learn more
  Send as gift   Add to Wish List

Almost ready!

In order to save audiobooks to your Wish List you must be signed in to your account.

      Log in       Create account

In the spirit of Colleen Hoover, a sweeping, poignant coming-of-age story about three identical sisters who each fall in love with the same boy next door, calling into question everything they know about themselves and their sisterhood.

Three sisters. Three love stories. A secret that changes everything.


Phoebe, Eliza, and Rose are three identical sisters who couldn’t be more different. When they’re seventeen, a beautiful boy moves in next door and nobody is surprised when Angus and Phoebe fall in love. Everybody loves Phoebe. But is she the sister he’s meant to be with? When Phoebe spends a summer in the French Alps, she meets a man who makes her wonder the same question.
 
Ten years later, it’s two weeks until Phoebe’s wedding when something unexpected changes all of their lives. Eliza will have to face a love from her past, one that could unmoor her or finally mend her broken heart. Meanwhile Rose, who has always been the responsible one, is ready for change—but is she ready for the man fate will bring? Angus will always be the boy next door in each of their hearts, but who is each sister meant to fall in love with?

Paige Toon grew up between England, Australia, and America and has been writing emotional love stories since 2007. She has published fifteen novels, a three-part spin-off series for young adults, and a collection of short stories. Her books have sold nearly 2 million copies worldwide. She lives in Cambridgeshire, England, with her husband and their two children.

IBD balloon logo

Shop the sale

In celebration of Independent Bookstore Day, shop our limited-time sale on bestselling audiobooks from April 22nd-28th. Don’t miss out—purchases support your local bookstore!

Shop now

Reviews

Praise for Paige Toon

“Nobody writes angst and joy and hope like Paige Toon.”—Christina Lauren, author of The Unhoneymooners and Love and Other Words

“Paige Toon is the queen of heart-rending love stories.”—Sophie Cousens, author of Just Haven’t Met You Yet

“Paige Toon's romances are powerful and poignant and never fail to leave me clutching her book to my chest.” —Mia Sheridan, author of Archer’s Voice and Travis

“Toon’s writing is emotional and riveting.”—Jill Santopolo, author of The Light We Lost

“Toon urges us to risk everything, to never play it safe when it comes to the heart, and to know that caring is always, always, worth the cost.” —Caroline Leavitt, author of Pictures of You and With or Without You

“Unique and moving.” —Josie Silver, author of One Day in December

“Only Paige Toon can make me believe in the power of love this way.” —Laura Jane Williams, author of Our Stop and The Love Square

“Devoured in one sitting.” —Cosmopolitan

“Paige Toon writes beautiful, emotional love stories.”Beth O’Leary, author of The Flatshare and The Road Trip

“Emotional.” —Publishers Weekly

“Compulsively page-turning, wildly romantic and beautifully heartbreaking.”—Emily Stone, author of Always in December

“Paige Toon is the queen of will they/won’t they romance, setting up an ending that will leave you in bits.” —The Sunday Express (UK)

“Queen of rom coms.” —OK Magazine (UK)


Praise for The One We Fell in Love With

“You’ll love it, cry buckets and be uplifted.” —Marian Keyes, author of Sushi for Beginners

“Devoured this is one sitting.” —Cosmopolitan

“I blubbed, I laughed, and I fell in love…Utterly heart-wrenching.” —Giovanna Fletcher, author of Eve of Man

“Brilliant characters and heart-fluttering romance….This poignant novel was a constant surprise, packing not only a whirlwind of emotions on every page, but also a hugely gripping story—and we fell absolutely in love with it’ —Heat (UK)

“For smart romantic fiction, look no further….Prepare yourself for a massive twist.” —Red (UK)

“A beautiful story of love and loss.” —My Weekly (UK)

“Expect tears, twists and belly laughs as Paige Toon, the queen of chick-lit, is back and better than ever.” —New (UK)

“This fresh take on the good old-fashioned fairy tale will make you laugh and cry.” —Closer (UK)

‘This is an enjoyable read, populated with engaging characters—I couldn’t put it down’ —Daily Mail (UK)

“Funny, smart and properly emosh, this ticks all our must-read boxes.” —Fabulous, Sun on Sunday (UK) Expand reviews
Celebrate indie bookstores with our limited-time sale! Shop the sale